The Key Differences Between Retaining Walls and Breast Walls

Retaining walls and breast walls are two slope-stabilizing structures that often look similar but serve very different engineering purposes. Understanding the difference between a retaining wall and a breast wall is Important for choosing the right solution for soil retention, hill-road safety, erosion control, and site development.

What is a Retaining Wall?

---

A retaining wall is a structural system built to hold back soil and resist lateral earth pressure. It creates two different ground levels and prevents soil movement, especially on sloping or unstable terrain.

Retaining walls are commonly used to:

• Support cut or fill slopes
• Prevent erosion
• Create usable platforms on uneven land
• Protect roads, highways, and foundations

Key Features of Retaining Walls

1. Purpose

A retaining wall’s primary job is to hold soil in place and resist active earth pressure. This allows engineers to shape land safely and create level surfaces where natural slopes exist.

2. Materials

Retaining walls may be built using:

• Reinforced concrete
• Stone masonry
• Brick
• Timber
• Gabion baskets
• Precast blocks

3. Types of Retaining Walls

Common designs include:

• Gravity Walls – rely on weight
• Cantilever Walls – use a reinforced footing and stem
• Counterfort Walls – used for taller heights
• Sheet Pile Walls – used in soft soils
• Anchored Walls – reinforced using ground anchors

These types are selected based on soil condition, height, drainage needs, and load requirements.

4. Drainage Requirement

Proper drainage is critical. Without weep holes, filter media, and drainage pipes, water pressure builds up and increases the risk of failure.

Applications of Retaining Walls

• Landscaping and garden terraces
• Basement and foundation support
• Highway and railway embankments
• Flood control and water channeling structures
• Industrial and residential site development

What Is a Breast Wall?

---

A breast wall is a protective structure built on the uphill side of a slope to prevent the surface soil from slipping downward. Unlike retaining walls, breast walls do not resist deep lateral pressure. They mainly stabilize the top layer of soil and prevent erosion on steep, natural slopes.

Key Features of Breast Walls

1. Purpose

To provide lateral support to the surface soil of a slope and reduce erosion, especially in hilly regions.

2. Materials

Breast walls are typically built with:

• Dry or cement stone masonry
• Plain or reinforced concrete

Because they support only shallow soil, they are generally smaller in dimension than retaining walls.

3. Construction Orientation

They are built parallel to the slope and follow the natural contour of the hill.

4. Design Nature

Breast walls are lighter, shorter, and less massive than retaining walls since they don’t support large soil volumes.

Applications of Breast Walls

• Hill road safety
• Railway line protection
• Mountain cutting support
• Soil erosion prevention
• Slope beautification and stabilization

Retaining Wall vs. Breast Wall: Key Differences

---

A simple way to understand the difference:

• Retaining Wall = supports heavy soil loads
• Breast Wall = supports surface soil and prevents erosion

Here is a detailed comparison:

Feature	Retaining Wall	Breast Wall
Primary Purpose	Retains soil and resists deep lateral pressure	Stabilizes surface soil and prevents erosion
Location	Built on the lower side of a slope	Built on the uphill side of a slope
Load Supported	Heavy soil load	Light surface load
Design Size	Larger, thicker, structurally complex	Smaller, simpler construction
Drainage Need	Essential (weep holes, filters, drainage pipes)	Less critical but still recommended
Common Materials	RCC, masonry, sheet piles, gabions	Mainly stone masonry or concrete
Terrain Suitability	Plains, slopes, cut/fill areas	Mountainous and hilly areas
Construction Cost	Higher	Lower
Failure Risk	High if drainage fails	Moderate, mainly due to erosion

When Should Engineers Use a Retaining Wall vs. a Breast Wall?

---

Use a Retaining Wall When:

• You need to hold back large volumes of soil
• You are creating different levels of ground
• The structure is close to a building foundation or highway
• The height is more than 2–3 m
• Soil is loose, saturated, or unstable

Use a Breast Wall When:

• You want to protect natural hill slopes
• The soil slip depth is shallow
• Building a hill road, rail line, or small drainage channel
• You need an economical slope protection solution

Common Failures in Both Structures

---

Retaining Wall Failures

• Poor drainage ➝ increased hydrostatic pressure
• Weak foundation design
• Overturning due to underestimated soil pressure
• Incorrect backfill selection

Breast Wall Failures

• Deep slips beyond the wall’s intended support
• Lack of toe support
• Improper masonry bonding
• Drainage water scouring the downhill soil

FAQs – Frequently Asked Questions